cloudsoup

no soup, no clouds

Policy-based evidence

leave a comment

Sex offenders in some parts of England and Wales will be made to take compulsory lie detector tests to see if they are still a danger to the public

The BBC, Sex offenders to face lie tests

Eye-catching policy from MiniJust, there. Trouble is, polygraphs are crap. From the BPS:

that even in the most favourable circumstances polygraphic lie detection accuracy is not high…People who are major threats may
well have strong incentives and sufficient resources to use countermeasures effectively…Research on the polygraph has not progressed over time in the manner of a typical scientific field.

A review of the current scientific status and
fields of application of Polygraphic Deception
Detection
(PDF)

Never mind. The money wasted won’t be missed and this lot will be out in the next General Election.

Written by David

September 19th, 2008 at 1:40 pm

Leave a Reply